Call for free independent agent advice
Your local agents ranked - see who's right for you
Home › Articles › Australian Property Prices and Data Explained
This guide originally compared four Australian property data providers in 2013. PropTrack, owned by REA Group, now also publishes a monthly Home Price Index. The four providers covered were:
Table of Contents
Real Estate sales prices are sourced directly from real estate agents and from Australia’s various State land title offices who collect information for stamp duty purposes (see NSW property sales information).
This data was used differently by the above companies to determine if prices were rising or falling. The following comparison describes the methods discussed in the original 2013 guide, as Macrobusiness.com.au described them:
ABS and APM use variants of the stratified median price method, which controls for changes in the composition of properties sold by separating the total sample of properties into a number of geographical sub-samples, and then into different strata based on the long-term average price level of properties in those regions. APM separately measures both capital city house and unit prices, whereas the ABS measures detached house prices only. As the ABS and APM methodologies are closely aligned, they often mirror each other’s house price movements. See here for the ABS’s methodological explanation.
Residex used a repeat sales methodology, similar to the Case-Shiller Index in the United States, which calculates price changes based upon repeat sales of the same homes. In order to minimise the price-distorting effects that renovations have on home prices, Residex also employed a combination of the hedonic technology and stratified median index technologies used by the other providers.
Finally RP Data-Rismark publishes a hedonic index, which measures price changes for both detached houses and units on a like-for-like basis according to their key attributes, such as location, land size, number of bedrooms and bathrooms, and so on. In March 2012, RP Data-Rismark moved from a monthly index to reporting price changes on a daily non-seasonally adjusted basis, which has led to significant volatility in their results, as well as a question mark over whether it lags the other less frequent indices. You can read more about RP Data-Rismark’s daily index here.
It is important to understand the limitations of the underlying data. There is a large lag between when the property is sold (exchanged) and when this is reported to the relevant land titles office. This lag means indices are constructed from a relatively small sample set as the majority of the transactions are yet to be reported. APM and the ABS report quarterly to incorporate as much reported data as possible before publication and both revise prior quarter figures (sometimes significantly). RPData-Rismark publishes more frequently – monthly and daily – and has received some negative press of late due to this, particularly from Louis Christopher of SQM Research.
Louis claimed the RPData-Rismark daily index was factually incorrect as he states it was reporting a daily index based on transactions which actually exchanged many months ago (see his claims here and here). His analysis of the sales reported to various land titles offices in May 2013 found that on average they were delayed as follows:
From RPData-Rismark’s response it is clear that their daily index does not directly including past sales into the daily result moreover it factors in where properties were exchanged and this information is used, in addition to exchanges that actually occurred on that day, to form a view of the current market movement.
Unfortunately there is no clear answer. It all depends on:
Each methodology has it’s pros and cons. For example from a theoretical standpoint RP Data-Rismark’s hedonic approach is preferred by some of Australia’s leading academic economists such as Professor Robert Hill however it does rely on an accurate data set of individual property characteristics (land size, bedrooms, bathrooms etc). This quality of this information currently available is fairly average, as most agents will tell you.
The somewhat simpler stratified median measures developed by RBA economists (Richards and Prasad) are used by the ABS and APM. This methodology can be adversely impacted by changes to the mix of buyers in the market as well as variations in the quality and type of properties manufactured over time. In the original August 2013 comparison, the ABS house-price index covered detached houses in capital cities, APM covered houses and units in capital cities, and Residex and RP Data-Rismark also covered regional price changes.
The Reserve Bank of Australia, Australia’s preeminent analytical body primarily references the RP Data-Rismark (see Dwelling Prices here), ABS and APM indices. The indices produced by the Real Estate Institutes and Residex are generally less cited. As macrobusiness.com.au recently showed over time the indices track each other fairly closely.
We suggest viewing each index in light of the above limitations and a blended approach is prudent. For current figures, compare Cotality’s daily and monthly home-value indices with Domain’s quarterly house-price reports and the ABS’s quarterly dwelling statistics. These publications measure different things, so their figures are not directly interchangeable.
Start your agent search now to obtain a quote from your top three local real estate agents and to understand the exact costs involved in selling a house and what your house is worth.
Property Advertised Prices Explained
Reflecting on Productivity – Crucial Property Price Driver
Reach out to one of our knowledgeable team members below.
Start your free comparison.